Dear Mr. Clooney,
I feel it is in your best interest that I write you this letter. Please know, that I am a fan and I have a high respect for your willingness to do good work as an actor as opposed to simply making millions and I respect your politics regarding legislation and the current state of affairs. Having said that, what is up with you?
Last weekend, The Good German came out here in Dallas. Your movie about an American military journalist in Berlin caught up in a murder investigation sounds alluring along with the whole Casablanca look the movie goes for. I’ll definitely check it out but I had to shake my head at yet, another Clooney-Soderbergh venture.
I’m worried that your and director Steven Soderbergh’s love-fest for each other is becoming…well…boring. And predictable. Mr. Clooney, I implore you to look into other ventures with other good and even better directors. I’d be most interested to see what Scorsese could do with you (provided he gets over his DiCaprio love-fest himself). Spielberg and you could make quite a pairing. Sam Mendes, Ang Lee, Jonathan Demme. Heck, Woody Allen. I’m almst willing to see you in a Michael Bay action movie. Just anybody other than Soderbergh for once.
I imagine you are quite aware of this but maybe you’ve never looked at it from outside the box. Let’s take a look shall we? The following is from IMDB. Anything before Out of Sight won’t count and I’ve deleted any television or unnecessary inclusion:
Ocean’s Thirteen (2007) - directed by SS
Michael Clayton (2007)
The Good German (2006) - directed by SS
Syriana (2005)
Good Night, and Good Luck. (2005)
Ocean’s Twelve (2004) - directed by SS
Intolerable Cruelty (2003)
Confessions of a Dangerous Mind (2002)
Solaris (2002) - directed by SS
Ocean’s Eleven (2001) - directed by SS
The Perfect Storm (2000)
O Brother, Where Art Thou? (2000)
Three Kings (1999)
The Thin Red Line (1998)
Out of Sight (1998) - directed by SS
So it may not look like much that only six of your last 15 movies were directed by Soderbergh. Heck, DeNiro had eight with Scorsese. But I can’t let you off so easily. See, this ‘thing’ between you and Soderbergh has become more of an octopus with tentacles in all directions. At first it seems like a Clooney thing because of your constant pairing with Mark Wahlberg a la Three Kings, The Perfect Storm and you producing Rock Star (which we won’t bring up again) but then Ocean’s Eleven is where it started with you and Steven.
Now let’s look at Confessions of a Dangerous Mind - your directorial debut. Oh, look, Sodie was an exec producer. And look, your costar Julia Roberts is in your movie as she was in O11 and O12 as she was in Erin Brockovich directed by none other. Let’s not forget her failed venture with SS, Full Frontal. We can forgive Damon’s and Pitt’s cameos in your movie since that was all in fun.
You went to Intolerable Cruelty with the Coen Brothers but that doesn’t give you much reprieve as you had worked with them previously on O Brother Where Art Thou. I’m sensing a pattern. You play it safe.
Your brilliant Good Night and Good Luck was high on my list for that year. Great job. It should have won best picture. I see Sodie is an exec producer again. But in that same year, you won an Oscar for starring in Syriana. A movie NOT directed by SS. Hey great. But remember that tentacle thing I mentioned? Your director Stephen Gaghan also wrote Traffic which I believe was directed by, oh, I don’t know…Steven Soderbergh? Also starring Catherine Zeta Jones who was in O12 as the daughter of Albert Finney’s character who also starred in Traffic AND Erin Brockovich. Lest we forget Damon was along for the ride in Syriana. Codependent much?
Let’s not stop there. You and Sodie exec produced Insomnia with Al Pacino, who I believe will be in O13 according to the trailers. And then there was Far from Heaven with Oscar nominee Julianne Moore and Patricia Clarkson who was in GNGL.
From my findings, the only movie you and Stevie produced that didn’t tie into anywhere else (yet) was Adrien Brody’s The Jacket. However, I won’t be surprised if any from that cast will end up in either of your movies.
So what’s the deal? I was almost impressed to find your next movie Michael Clayton had no ties but then Sodie was listed as producer. And at what point is it all a little TOO incestuous? I fail to find coincidence in the following:
Cate Blanchett with you in German and Pitt in Babel (with Damon in Mr. Ripley but that was a long time ago)
Pitt and Roberts in The Mexican
Zeta Jones and Pitt in Sinbad
Zeta Jones and Roberts in American Sweethearts
and then we can start going on a limb here–
Pitt and Jolie in M/M Smith.
Jolie and Damon in the Good Shepherd
Damon and Wahlberg in The Departed
and so on and so on.
Maybe it’s a Clooney - Soderbergh Dynasty. Maybe I’m thinking too much about it. But I’m concerned about you. Break away just once and let loose. Let me see you and Jodie Foster, Paul Giamatti or any actor who can challenge you. Maybe Spike Lee? Hook up with Tarantino again if you can. Just do something different and soon because now you’re comfortable. And we, the audience, already know what to expect from you. What actor wants that? You’re already a class act. Quit trying to convince us you are.

Best of luck, Mr. Clooney. On my way to see Pursuit of Happyness starring that Men In Black guy.
Rich
cc: Steven Soderbergh
cc: Brad Pitt